Poll: Which 1 in 360 finalist had the best audition video?
20After months of build-up, the participation of several national final veterans, allegations of fraudulent voting, and a behind-closed-doors jury vote, San Marino has whittled 557 submissions down to just 11 artists for its 1 in 360 national final.
In 2018 Camilla North, Emma Sandstrom, Franklin Calleja, Giovanni Montalbano, Irol, Jenifer Besky, Jessika, Judah Gavra, Sara de Blue, Sebastian Schmidt and Tinashe Makura will each perform live in front of a panel of judges — and Eurofans watching online — with the hope of advancing deep in the competition.
Assessing the pre-contest favourite isn’t easy, and there are several ways to break it down. Many would give that title to Emma from Finland. She entered UMK 2017 as a huge fan favourite and seemed to cement her status as the fandom’s preferred candidate by winning the Fan Vote Wildcard. It seems the technical stumbles at UMK — and her classy response on YouTube — have only added fuel to her fire.
But, of course, national final veterans Franklin Calleja and Judah Gavra also made the Top 3 in the Fan Vote Wildcard, suggesting they are in the theoretical mix too. Ultimately it all comes down to the live performances in the new year.
Others may argue that the Fan Vote Wildcard isn’t necessarily representative of Eurovision fans at large, but rather the vocal slice of it and those who join fan groups. There is a silent majority who aren’t active on social media or in various groups, and who dip in on the day of the contests to enjoy the music and cast their votes.
One way to potentially reach this wider set of fans is to look at the second wildcard, where people simply gave hearts to the acts they enjoyed. Certainly the number of unique votes cast would be higher than the number of people in the fan groups that decided that wildcard.
Here Italy’s Giovanni Monalbano was the clear winner…though his nearly 400,000 votes have been questioned by many. Discounting that number, we see the finalist with the highest number of votes was Malta’s Jessika, who finished 12th among the 557 submissions with 17,921 votes.
Camilla North from Norway was the only other finalist who managed to make the Top 32. She earned 1,206 votes.
Second wildcard vote
Entries: 557
Singers with at least 1,000 votes: 32
Singers with at least 2,000 votes: 22
Singers with at least 5,000 votes: 17
Singers with at least 10,000 votes: 15
Singers with at least 25,000 votes: 9
Singers with at least 50,000 votes: 6
Singers with at least 200,000 votes: 5
Singers with at least 300,000 votes: 2
1. Giovanni Montalbano (Italy) 388,633
2. GLORIA ZACCARIA (Italy) 382,237
3. Julian Lesi?ski (Poland) 203,579
4. Miguel Vicente (Spain) 190,879
5. Tom Hartis (France) 112,313
6. Marcus Reischmann (Germany) 50,045
7. Yana Gloushak (Russia) 33,649
8. Dario Mifsud Bonnici (Malta) 33,127
9. Stavros Pilichos (Greece) 28,208
10. Mac Zavadsky (Poland) 23,448
11. Camilla Dentale (Italy) 18,219
12. Jessika (Malta) 17,921
13. HIlary Smile (Italy) 15,169
14. Sofya Angel Barocco (Russia) 15,115
15. Benjamin Coveliers (Belgium) 10,388
16. Sebastian Calleja (Malta) 6,494
17. Panagiotis Mademlis (Greece) 6,232
18. Maika Barbero (Spain) 4,853
19. Raylan Arbizu (Spain) 4,446
20. William and Deban (United Kingdom) 3,423
21. Elena Petresca (Macedonia) 2,714
22. René Reith-Schäfer (Germany) 2,027
23. Bjorn Rosier (Belgium) 1,939
24. Oyku Dogan (Turkey) 1,896
25. Ones Antoine (Haiti) 1,739
26. Elisa “ELYSA” Kolk (Estonia) 1,494
27. Eduard Alexogiannopoulos (Greece) 1,403
27. Dario & Grecia Bezzina (Malta) 1,403
29. Andi Taranik (Belarus) 1,330
30. Dionisis Kostis (Greece) 1,269
31. Camilla North (Norway) 1,206
32. Marco Antonio Gaitano (Spain) 1,030
Putting numbers aside altogether, some fans would argue that IROL is the act with the sentimental and emotional advantage, owing to the fact he is actually from San Marino. The Sammarinese population is small, but if everyone with a TV votes for him, he could well have a fighting chance.
In any case, all of these theories and suggestions will likely disappear the moment the acts go live. Voice and song will make you or break you.
So for now we simply want to know: Which 1 in 360 finalist had the best audition video? You can watch all of them at the links below. Then vote in our poll. You can vote for as many acts as you’d like, but you can only vote one time, so make it count.
1 in 360 finalists
- Camilla North (Norway)
- Emma Sandstrom — Fan Vote Wildcard (Finland)
- Franklin Calleja (Malta)
- Giovanni Montalbano — Video Likes Wildcard (Italy)
- Irol — San Marino Wildcard (San Marino)
- Jennifer Besky (Germany)
- Jessika (Malta)
- Judah Gavra (Israel)
- Sara de Blue (Austria)
- Sebastian Schmidt (Germany)
- Tinashe Makura (Zimbabwe)
December 31, 2017 @ 3:24 pm
So dissapointed, I was rooting for Deban and William
December 31, 2017 @ 1:43 am
Preliminary, without a final song, I’d say Jessika. That woman proved that she really wants to participate in ESC. Too bad The Flame is now ineligible.
December 31, 2017 @ 1:34 am
BAD SELECTION WITHOUT EMOTIONS AND TALENT
December 30, 2017 @ 9:54 pm
William and Deban Underrated
December 30, 2017 @ 10:03 pm
LOL thank you
December 30, 2017 @ 9:15 pm
The poll results (at time of writing) show Emma with a clear lead, over Sara De Blue and Irol. Coincidentally these are also my top three. 🙂
December 30, 2017 @ 7:32 pm
This Jennifer Besky is really good! Great cover of “Chandelier”. I hope she sings the same way live. I also like Jessika.
From all these artists, I believe the best choice is Sara de Blue. He has her own style and personality, a beautiful voice without trying to showcase her vocal abilities all the time. If she’s given the right song, she will be great for San Marino.
December 30, 2017 @ 7:25 pm
Irol for the win!!
December 30, 2017 @ 6:20 pm
Emma feat. Iron for the win! 🙂
December 30, 2017 @ 6:21 pm
*IROL (damn auto-correct!)
December 30, 2017 @ 10:04 pm
This is an intriguing idea!
December 30, 2017 @ 11:32 pm
Indeed. I think Robyn Gallagher first suggested the idea, in a YouTube comment. But others have had the same idea since. San Marino producers: Please Take Note. 🙂
December 30, 2017 @ 5:48 pm
In my opinion Emma had the best audition
December 30, 2017 @ 5:14 pm
Camilla North: I think she tries a little too hard to make “Hallelujah” sound more emotional than it already is. There were so many words that she put an emphasis on that in the end her entire performance seemed a little flat.
Emma Sandström: It’s hard to judge someone’s singing abilities based on a mobil phone video shot in a hallway… I guess she’s the kind of singer who could sing pretty much any song. Her style is not too special, but it isn’t bad either.
Franklin Calleja: I’m not really a fan of his voice, to be honest. I guess he’s someone who is ready to perform any cheesy ballad that he’s given without batting an eyelid.
Giovanni Montalbano: He’s got a nice voice that goes well with Italian-style mid-tempo songs or ballads. His style might come across a little boring on the big Eurovision stage.
Irol: I like that contribution (probably mainly because of the song). It’s hard to judge live vocal abilities and charisma from that video though.
Jennifer Besky: Strong (albeit a little flat) voice. Again, it’s a little too much of everything for me. Good enough for Karaoke night, maybe not good enough for Eurovision.
Jessika: She has yet to find her own style. Her voice is okay but she could pay more attention to the words she’s singing. She never indulges in her songs.
Judah Gavra: Was he chosen because of his singing abilities? Really? His 2013 Kdam live performance was not too promising. His voice is one-dimensional and I don’t think he’s charismatic enough to get away with it.
Sara de Blue: She tends to scream a little too much (but that’s something she could work on). She has probably the most complex voice out of the 11 contestants and I do think she might be able to attract the audience’s attention.
Sebastian Schmidt: Another decent voice but also another case of “contrived emotionality”. Based on the video, I have literally no idea if he would be able to fill the Eurovision stage performing a decent song.
Tinashe Makura: Not a great voice, but great charisma. With a simple, happy tune he might get some votes for San Marino. Right now, I can’t picture him perform anything else, though.
Overall, I don’t think that any of the 11 acts is either “Eurovision ready” or “different enough so that he/she might as well not give a sh*t what the Eurovision audience is expecting and do his/her thing”. However, I see some potential and there is definitely a lot of work to be done.
We shouldn’t forget that San Marino’s major problem have always been the songs anyway.
December 30, 2017 @ 5:21 pm
Really interesting and honest analysis! And you’re right: San Marino needs to keep Ralph Siegel at bay and get a MODERN 2018 SONG.
December 30, 2017 @ 6:32 pm
Lol, Ralph Siegel also tried it in Germany many many times… Why is this man still trying?He just doesn’t have any Talent for creating good modern song… When you don’t have talent for something maybe someday you should just stop..
December 30, 2017 @ 7:02 pm
We shouldn’t forget that Siegel has strong connections to Malta. Actually, I think that Jessika is the kind of artist he’s collaborate with.
December 30, 2017 @ 7:02 pm
*he’d
December 30, 2017 @ 4:27 pm
Irol. Not just because he’s from San Marino, but he’s actually very good. “Irol feat. Emma” would be the perfect match.
I hope the selection won’t be just a “singing competition”. They all can sing very well, it seems.
December 30, 2017 @ 9:06 pm
I’m firmly on team “Irol feat. Emma”. They would be a power pair!