In March he said that postponing Eurovision 2020 would have been better than cancelling it. And now that the EBU has announced Eurovision: Europe Shine A Light — the official replacement show for broadcast on May 16 — San Marino’s Carlo Romeo is speaking up again.
In an extensive interview with Eurovision In, the director-general of San Marino Radio Television says that he pitched another programme idea which involved raising awareness about the coronavirus pandemic and also raising funds to help provide support and relief. He also questions why the EBU communicated the announcement of the cancellation through social media. “We found out that some of our partners and sponsors had the news before us, a direct member of the EBU,” he says. “Scandalous.”
Eurovision In: How did you react to the EBU’s decision to cancel Eurovision 2020 and what had you proposed?
Carlo Romeo: Here at San Marino RTV our first reaction was rejecting the contest’s cancellation and proposing holding it in October. When we were asked for an alternative proposal, we pitched a competition for the day of the Grand Final. A show that serves as public service, explaining the coronavirus situation country by country with a choral song as opening act, a competition, a jury and a televote. The direction we were aiming for was more like public service but keeping the competition.
How did the EBU react to your proposal?
They answered thanking us for the idea and explaining that soon we would be informed about their final idea. A show that would have incorporated some of parts of our proposal.
Shortly after they revealed Europe: Shine a Light. Some small parts of our proposal were indeed included, but they completely missed the central concept of the public service function, removing the competition which as we all know is the main appeal.
Have RAI also proposed a competition like you have?
These weeks RAI and San Marino RTV have been working closely. RAI worked on a project very close to ours, keeping the competition and the informative segments with an extra benefit aspect, as people would be able to donate to their national health organizations – something similar to “Musica che Unisce”. At this point here at San Marino RTV we completely endorsed RAI’s proposal, as we deemed it adequate for the current times.
Do you think Europe: Shine a Light is the best proposal the EBU could’ve put forward?
It is a completely inadequate proposal in its content, during these times and in its manners. It just gives the impression of an event that got out of hand. Without a contest, the appeal —as we all know— is almost non-existent and it won’t really be a show in the way it was presented, a way to unite European broadcasters that are acting together in this emergency situation.
How have your proposals been received?
The proposal to reject the cancellation and any form of cancellation favoring a postponement in October has had excellent responses from some Heads of Delegation, artists and producers who have been working on this since July. Regarding the proposal of the competitive format for May 16th, I believe that if all the stakeholders make themselves heard in the next few hours, as on Tuesday there is an important EBU deadline on this, we can avoid missing a unique opportunity. We need courage, a true European sense and not a facade, imagination. Above all, courage and ability to face the emergency. I don’t want to name people, but the ESC leaders, or rather I should say the ESC leader, whose adequacy I personally have been doubting for a long time given previous incidents, confirmed the unsuitability even under these circumstances.
How did you find the EBU’s communication regarding the cancelation?
We find it totally unacceptable that we were informed through social media. We hope that those who violated the rules have been inquired by those in duty and we would be pleased to have some news on the matter. We found out that some of our partners and sponsors had the news before us, a direct member of the EBU. Scandalous.
If RAI’s proposal was ignored what would you do?
Obviously we hope that RAI’s project receives its deserved attention. It is a beautiful project, certainly more solid than ours, and I am sure that France, Germany, Spain and all the others will take it into consideration. Sweden, as well as other broadcasters, have shown courage and imagination for May 16 with their individual initiatives, but in doing so, the idea of united European television comes out in pieces if you are forced to go each one on their own. We will most likely join for Europe: Shine A Light. However, we will continue to underline once again the inadequacy of the proposal as it was presented. We will continue, I hope not only us, to support RAI’s project or any other proposals that go in the same direction. Coronavirus cannot and must not repeal European television in any way.
Where do you stand on all of this? Do you think the show should have a “competition” aspect? Do you think the show should have a strong focus on coronavirus education? Let us know down below.